Louise Gough
Director of Narrative Content
Screen Australia
GPO Box 3984
Sydney, NSW 2001 19th. November 2026
Dear Louise
You have chosen, yet again, to ignore my letter of 14th November.
You are in good company. The Screen Australia Board ignores my letters also.
Ostriches!
The Screen Australia wagons have circled.
“Ignore James, he’ll give up asking for evidence eventually.”
No, he won’t!
I may have burnt all my Screen Australia bridges by pursuing justice for myself, but if my career as an Australian filmmaker is, as far as Screen Australia is concerned, is at the end, it will end with a bang and not with a whimper.
Ideally, Louise, you should be engaging with screenwriters - meeting them face to face, listening to them, discussing, debating, arguing with them creatively about their projects, allowing them to pitch, convince you that you are wrong.
Not every applicant, of course, but with experienced screenwriters with track records, yes.
Sending form letters of rejection (that read as though written by a chatbot) and forcing screenwriters to make an FOI application to acquire notes relating to the rejection, reveals either a lack of professional respect or a structural problem within Screen Australia designed to keep applicants and staff apart.
This is, I guess, based on some past bureaucrat’s presumption that words on paper, ticks in boxes, percentile scores, spread sheets, etc. are the best determinants of which narrative projects are deserving of support, and which can safely be allowed to wither on the vine.
Check box office results: Australian films usually attract beneath 1 % of receipts in any one week.
If you seriously believe that you and your anonymous assessors are ‘industry experts’ you are deluding yourselves.
If you were ‘experts’, there would be a long list of Aussie movies funded by Screen Australia in development and production that Aussie audiences were queueing up to see.
There are no queues. Why?
Shows such as this have been made many times this last 20 years and some of them are very good, but it would be great if SA developed something original every now and then. Like ADOLESCENCE or BABY REINDEER. These two series rated through the roof BECAUSE the relevant creative decision-makers took risks.
When did Screen Australia last take a risk?
Our ‘industry’, the products of which Aussie audiences shy away from, requires better films.
Better films require better screenplays.
Your application modus operandi needs to be overhauled. Or, at the very least, there needs to be public discussion, debate, dialogue about the possible need for a major rethink about ‘narrative development’.
We screenwriters need to be a part of it. Without screenwriters there can be no narrative films. Treat us with at least a modicum of respect.
The two attachments (Hemingway and Murakami) provide examples of great writers whose writing modus operandi would render them unable to meet Screen Australia’s stringent tick-in-box application requirements.
I agree with Ernest Hemmingway about writing draft after draft before locking off a story.
If only Screen Australia was as vigilant in its demands for script re-writes before greenlighting mediocre projects!
And Murakami articulates a truth about the writing process that your resident ‘experts’ would do well to bear in mind. My writing modus operandi is very similar to his, though I only walk 5 – 7 kms and swim a kilometre a day.
As other screenwriters about their writing modus operandi and adapt your application processes to cater for them. Don’t insist that all screenwriters work in accordance with SA application processes. I will use myself as an example here:
I have three completed TV drama series writing in my own way, and have started work on a fourth. None of these has received one dollar of development funding since I was banned in 2012. Even if there had been no ban, at no stage in the development of any of these would my writing modus operandi, very similar to Murakami’s, have been in sync with Screen Australia’s assessment requirements.
I do not write ‘bibles’, ignore any treatments or synopses I write under duress and let the Muse take me where She wishes – at least until I have a first draft that I am happy with.
I am not able to make an impartial assessment of the quality of these three series, but nor is Screen Australia given its propensity for form letters of rejection and the impossibility of talking with a warm-blooded flesh and blood human being at SA.
And now, even with completed works, I cannot speak with you or any of your resident ‘experts’ because...
Because, why?
When I was banned from making applications back in 2012, the Board banned me from even talking with members of Screen Australia staff.
This ban remains, it seems, 14 years down the track.
Really, Louise!
cheers
James Ricketson
Dear Deirdre and Louise,
Thanks for attaching your name to this email, Dierdre. I suggest that you do likewise, Louise. This is simply old-fashioned good manners, but it is also in sync with the requirements laid out in the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 and the Public Service Act 1999.
I am not going to try to order my thoughts here as I realise that it is a waste of my time. Make what you will of the following:
It is simply not true that you have adopted an AFC style assessment modus operandi. I assessed for the AFC for a dozen years, during which assessors were NOT anonymous and during which EVERY applicant had the opportunity to meet with assessors to pitch their project. Yes, at times a laborious and time-consuming process but one that led to the first films being made by Yahoo Serious, Alex Proyas and Jocelyn Moorhouse.
Yes, Screen Australia is a small agency. No, Screen Australia’s resources are not limited. SA has $96 million a year available to support Australian filmmakers – applying the word ‘filmmakers’ in the broadest sense of the word.
As CEO, Dierdre, you have chosen to devote only a very small proportion of this $96 million to script assessment processes. That this is bad policy is borne out by the number of lacklustre screenplays that emerge from your ‘anonymous expert’ assessment modus operandi.
Being ‘short-staffed’ is a choice you have made as CEO - so short-staffed that not one of your ‘experts’ can find fifteen minutes of his/her busy schedule to make a phone call to an award-winning screenwriter to discuss his application. In this instance THURSDAY’S CHILD was/is a project held in sufficiently high esteem by the Australian Film Commission for the AFC to make an in-principle investment of $700,000 in it.
Really, Deirdre and Louise? You have no doubts at all?
You write, Deirdre:
"Screen Australia is proud that the vast majority of its funding ends up on-screen, rather than inflating internal operating costs. I know you’d agree with this."
I disagree with this entirely. Your characterising script development costs as ‘internal operating costs’ betrays a lack of understanding of the foundational importance of screenplays to the success of films at the box office and/or as cultural artefacts.
Screen Australia’s objective should not be to fund as many films as possible but to see to it, through the important role it plays in development, that funded narrative projects are of the highest possible standard. It would be far preferable for SA to shepherd 7 high quality projects into production rather than 10 that are ‘good enough’. Quantity as opposed to quality is fine when it comes to hamburgers, perhaps, but a hamburger made with love and care is far tastier than one produced by McDonald's.
In brief, I think SA should concern itself with quality rather than quantity. This does not require 'experts'. It requires experienced professionals who have sufficient humility to acknowledge that they may be wrong; that perhaps the applicant is right in his/her approach to the development of his/her screenplay.
The original form letter of rejection, seemingly written by a bot, was not just insulting, but also factually incorrect. If it was not written by a bot, it was certainly not written by anyone who can (or should) proclaim him or herself to be an ‘expert’. An experienced screenwriter, an experienced producer or director would have looked at my copious notes and realised that s/he was dealing with an experienced professional who was entitled to be treated with respect – regardless of what s/he thought of the project. I was not an assessor for CROCODILE DUNDEE but I did read the screenplay at the time it arrived at the AFC. If I had been an assessor I would not have voted to fund it, and I would have been wrong. Very wrong, even though I was, at the time, what you now refer to as an ‘expert’.
Cheers,
James
No comments:
Post a Comment