Jackie Keast
Editor
IF Magazine 12th November 2026
Dear Jackie
On 20th May 2025, you declined to publish my Opinion piece “Why an Australian Film Industry.” You also declined to publish it as ‘Sponsored Content’ for reasons that do not pass the pub test.
I have written another piece that I think is worthy of publication and discussion relating, primarily, to the ‘Producer Offset’.
Again, I ask that you publish it. If you think that it is not well enough written or argued, or that it is irrelevant, please allow me to pay to have it published as ‘Sponsored Content’
cheers
James
Addendum
My 20th. May 2025 email to you re “Why an Australian Film Industry.”
Dear Jackie
It was never my intention to do anything other than update WHY AN AUSTRALIAN FILM INDUSTRY? and hope that it generated some debate.
However, given that you have decided not to publish it, and given that I can’t get answers to questions from either Screen Australia, I can’t help but wonder about the impact this secrecy, this funding body code of silence, this lack of bureaucratic transparency accountability, has on the feature films we make. I will mention only one here: script development.
On its website Screen Australia’s lists 70 assessors who decide which drama projects in development are greenlit and which left to wither on the vine. (attached)
The first thing that struck me on reading this list was the dearth of writers, directors and producers with decades of experience to be found on it, and the number of filmmakers on it with limited experience in drama.
Do these relatively inexperienced filmmakers get to decide which drama submissions will obtain development funding and which will not? It seems so. A question worthy of exploration, don’t you think?
One does not necessarily need to be an experienced filmmaker to be a competent and insightful assessor, of course, but the poor quality of screenplays that emerge from the Screen Australia assessment process should, at the very least, lead to questions being asked.
One suggestion:
Assess the assessors. How well do their assessments at all stages of development - from concept through to final draft - predict the quality of the film that is produced? Do the screenplays result in high quality distinctively Australian stories being told by Australians for Australian audiences? If it is clear, when the film is released and is a flop, that it has been produced from a second-rate screenplay, or, if a potentially fine screenplay was rushed into production a few drafts sooner than it should have been (a high proportion Australian feature films) are these assessors, and others within Screen Australian responsible for greenlighting these projects, fit for purpose?
Of course, no-one greenlighting projects has a perfect record. From both a box office and artistic point of view failure is an ever-present possibility. However, I think it is a truism to declare that great films are never made from lousy screenplays – of which we develop many too many.
As with WHY AN AUSTRALIAN FILM INDUSTRY?, I make the comments above because I believe in transparency, accountability, dialogue and debate. I would love to see IF Magazine providing a platform for such debate; badly needed debate, in my view.
Others in our film community will disagree with me, and so they should. Let them float their own ideas as to how we can produce feature films that Australian audiences want to see.
cheers
James
cc Screen Australia
The need for open discussion and debate remains – between filmmakers, funding bodies and those in Canberra who decide on what polices we must all abide by; navigate. This is particularly so as we enter an AI age in which the whole filmmaking game is changing with dizzying rapidity.
follow up letter
Jackie Keast
Editor
IF Magazine 17th November 2026
Dear Jackie
You have not responded to my letter of 12th. November.
Clearly, you have no intention of publishing my ‘Questions for Screen Australia’ Opinion piece as ‘Sponsored Content’.
Yet again!
I suspect that asking you why, is a waste of my time, but I will try:
“Why do you refuse to publish anything that I write as ‘Opinion’, in hopes of generating discussion within the film and television community?”
Not even if I offer to pay?
Do you not want such discussion to occur?
Do you think that the questions I asked of Screen Australia on 5th. November are irrelevant?
That there is nothing of substance to discuss?
The article you published in IF earlier in the year, quoting what Nick Hayes wrote in Made, Not Seen: The Misalignment of Australian Film, Cinema and Audiences, highlights many of the problems confronting Australian films, but ignores one:
We are not making films that Australian audiences want to see.
This is not just my opinion.
Look at last week’s Australian box office results:
$15.5 million, total
$131,163 for 16 Australian films
0.85% of the total.
As Nick Hayes observes, since the establishment of Screen Australia and introduction of the Producer Offset in 2008:
- Australian feature film output has grown by over 132%.
- box office returns for Australian film have declined by roughly 58% to 60%.
Aussie audiences want to go to the movies, just not to Aussie movies.
Why?
Isn’t this a topic that we should all be discussing, debating, with each other?
Filmmakers, and funding bodies alike?
Why is IF Magazine not at the centre of such a debate?
Encouraging it? Seeking out many opinions?
Or do other filmmakers with opinions different to mine also submit pieces that you refuse to publish?
I argue that one reason (of many) Aussies don’t go to Aussie movies is that our films are all-too-often mediocre, having been produced from mediocre screenplays that:
(1) were not yet ready to go into production – ’undercooked’
(2) lack originality
(3) do not relate to the lives of audiences who do not live inside the cultural urban bubbles that many filmmakers live within.
There are exceptions to this, of course, but box office receipts do not lie.
A quote from the earlier piece I wrote (“Filmmaking is Not Accountancy”) that you declined to publish:
Great films emerge from talented, unpredictable human beings whose gifts are not always obvious on paper. My fear is that anonymous assessment processes, the elimination of gut-instinct decisions by filmmaker/assessors, the proliferation of professional bureaucrat decision-makers, make it harder for funding bodies to recognise the potential in filmmakers who do not fit into the tick-in-a-box molds demanded by online application forms.
Some talented filmmakers struggle to express themselves in written applications. Others are dyslexic, shy, inexperienced or simply far better at communicating through images than words. Face-to-face meetings gave assessors the opportunity to recognise those strengths.
Given the role played by funding bodies in script development, the assessment modus operandi of them all needs, in my view to be completely overhauled.
Other filmmakers may disagree, but I believe that anonymous assessments made by assessors who lack the qualifications, the relevant craft and artistic skill to assess, is a problem that needs to be addressed.
The fact that assessors remain anonymous is also a problem, in that they can never be publicly held to account for their creative decisions.
It is a great pity, in my view, that IF Magazine does not want to play a role in generating much needed dialogue, discussion and debate.
It is also a pity that Screen Australia does not initiate such public debates.
We are, after all, in the same boat, and will sink or swim together.
In November 2026, the box office figures suggest that we are sinking.
cheers
James
cc Screen Australia
No comments:
Post a Comment